Fine-Tuning Google Maps
Thursday, November 22nd, 2007Google is letting users ‘fine-tune’ locations on Google maps. Don’t get me wrong. I like Google Maps, it’s just that I like Local Live more. It’s more accurate. By allowing people edit maps, Google is hoping to improve on accuracy.
Despite assurances from Google that map data won’t be abused, I’m skeptical. Google are planning to stop abuse by locking down of businesses already listed in Google Local Business Center, manual reviewing of locations moved by more that 200 yards and a similar mechanism to the ‘report spam’ operation in Jaiku.
Protection of business locations already listed in Google Local Business comes off as small potatoes. It currently only covers 25 countries including Ireland. How can Liechtenstein be covered and not Greece or Brazil? Not to mind, the up and comers in Eastern Europe like the Czech Republic, Poland or Romania. Or East Asian trading hubs like Thailand, Korean and Singapore.
Manual reviewing of locations? That sounds like an enormous job. Something that a team would need to be indefinitely committed to. How are these reviewers going to be trained? What’s to say that their qualifications lead them to be the best arbitrars of location? They must be cartographers, as the data necessary to approve many of these locations will require deep local knowledge.
Is there a time estimate on the approval? Perhaps, the suggested fix will join in a perpetual march to approval queue hell. If so, this will kill the appetite of community map-fixers that are making valid edits. They’ll get sick waiting for their fixes to be approved.
Reporting bad map-fixes is a good idea. Irate map users will be only too happy to vent. I believe some sort of review system should sit here too.
You want to counter this, Google - open you Local Business Center to more countries. Make the process more transparent. Offer incentives for big community map-fixers. Give them a taste for contributing to the map habitat. Build a real transcontinental community and be open about it.